Personal Loans
· Borderbuz Editorial Team

Borderbuz is an independent financial comparison platform. We may earn a commission when you click through.

Debt Consolidation Loans: The Halifax Problem and Better Alternatives

Halifax no longer accepts new loan applications, while HSBC lends up to £30,000 and NatWest focuses on one monthly repayment.

Advertisement

Quick Picks

Best current starting point: HSBC Personal Loan for Debt Consolidation for borrowing from £1,000 to £30,000, with terms reaching 96 months on loans above £15,000.
Best for one-payment simplicity: NatWest Debt Consolidation Loan, which is explicitly built around replacing several debts with one monthly repayment.
Best for existing Halifax borrowers: Halifax customers can keep their existing loan, but new applicants are directed to Lloyds instead.
Best alternative to Halifax: Lloyds Bank Debt Consolidation Loan, because Halifax’s new-loan route has closed.

Rates and terms shown are representative. Your actual rate depends on your credit profile and circumstances. This is not financial advice — always read the lender's terms before applying.

Reviewing debt consolidation options

The market has changed: Halifax is no longer a new-applicant option

The most important fact in this comparison is not a rate. Halifax’s own loan page says the brand is changing to Lloyds and that new Halifax loan applications are no longer available. Existing Halifax loans remain Halifax loans, but new borrowers are directed to Lloyds.

That makes this a practical comparison of current routes rather than five equal offers. NatWest, HSBC, Lloyds and Barclays still represent active bank-led paths in the supplied listings; Halifax is mainly relevant as a warning to check whether an apparently familiar product is still open to new applications.

Debt consolidation only improves your position if the new loan reduces the total cost or gives you a repayment schedule you can maintain. A lower monthly payment can simply mean a longer term. Before applying, add the balances being cleared, check for early-settlement charges on existing debts, and compare the new loan’s total repayment rather than focusing only on the monthly figure.

According to the Halifax loan page, new applicants should explore Lloyds instead. That is the unusual insight here: the highest-ranked listing is not actually available to new borrowers.

Current bank routes for replacing several debts

Three listings belong in the main comparison: NatWest, HSBC and Lloyds. They are not interchangeable. The useful differences are the stated borrowing range, repayment term and how clearly the page frames consolidation.

NatWest Debt Consolidation Loan

NatWest leads with the problem many borrowers actually want to solve: replacing several repayments with one monthly payment. Its page says consolidation could reduce the amount paid each month, but that is not proof of a lower total cost. Compare the new term and total repayment against your current balances before treating a smaller monthly bill as a saving. Compared with HSBC, NatWest’s supplied page gives less detail on the borrowing range and maximum term, so it is stronger on the consolidation message than on the numbers available for an initial comparison. Best for borrowers with several unsecured debts who want one scheduled repayment and are prepared to request a personalised quote before deciding.

You will stay on this site

HSBC Personal Loan for Debt Consolidation

HSBC provides the clearest figures in the supplied data: borrowing from £1,000 to £30,000, with fixed monthly payments for up to 60 months on loans up to £15,000 and up to 96 months above that threshold. The page also states that applicants can receive a quick credit decision and access funds after signing the agreement. That longer maximum term may reduce the monthly payment, but it can increase the interest paid across the life of the loan. Compared with NatWest, HSBC is easier to screen against a known debt balance; compared with Halifax, it is an active new-application route. Best for borrowers consolidating between £1,000 and £30,000 who need a clearly stated term range and can afford to compare total repayment, not just instalments.

You will stay on this site

Lloyds Bank Debt Consolidation Loan

Lloyds becomes the practical successor to Halifax in this set because Halifax directs new applicants there. The supplied Lloyds page confirms a dedicated debt-consolidation route, but it does not provide a rate, borrowing range or fee schedule in the available content. That missing detail matters: a bank name alone cannot establish that the loan will beat your existing weighted average rate. Compared with HSBC, Lloyds gives less information here for an early cost comparison; compared with Halifax, it is the route new applicants are actually told to use. Best for Halifax shoppers who need a current bank alternative and are willing to check the personalised APR, total repayment and any settlement conditions before accepting.

You will stay on this site

Those three routes show why a familiar bank name is not enough. HSBC gives the strongest upfront numbers, NatWest explains the consolidation use case most directly, and Lloyds is the relevant destination for new Halifax applicants despite the limited figures in the supplied page extract.

What Halifax’s closure means for borrowers

Halifax is not a normal fourth quote. Its page says new Halifax loans can no longer be applied for, while existing loans remain with Halifax. The lender therefore belongs in this guide as a status check rather than a recommendation for a fresh application.

Halifax Debt Consolidation Loan

Halifax is the item most likely to mislead a borrower who relies on an old comparison page. The supplied official page explicitly says new Halifax loan applications are closed and points applicants to Lloyds. Existing customers are told their current Halifax loan will remain Halifax, so this is not a statement that every Halifax loan has disappeared. Compared with the active listings, Halifax cannot be treated as a live quote for a new consolidation application. Best for existing Halifax borrowers checking what happens to their current agreement, not for someone seeking a new loan this month.

You will stay on this site
Checking an existing loan agreement

Barclays: a separate quote to test against the banks above

Barclays is included because its listing is specifically for debt consolidation, but the supplied page content does not show an APR, loan range, term, fee or eligibility threshold. Its displayed comparison price is 4.9, higher than the 3.9 figures attached to Halifax, NatWest and Lloyds and above HSBC’s 3.3 listing score. Those values are not labelled as APRs in the supplied data, so they should not be presented as interest rates.

Barclayloan Debt Consolidation

Barclays deserves a quote only after the missing pricing details are confirmed. The supplied listing identifies a debt-consolidation product, but it does not reveal the APR, borrowing range, repayment term, fees or eligibility rules needed to judge value. Its displayed price of 4.9 is also higher than the 3.9 figures attached to NatWest and Lloyds and the 3.3 figure attached to HSBC, although those listing prices are not defined as APRs. Compared with HSBC, Barclays offers less usable information at the research stage. Best for existing Barclays customers who want to request a direct comparison quote, especially if their current banking relationship produces personalised terms, but not for anyone ready to choose from headline data alone.

You will stay on this site

Comparison table: what the supplied pages actually tell you

LenderWhat is confirmedAvailable pricing detailBest for
NatWestDebt consolidation into one monthly paymentNot shown in supplied contentBorrowers prioritising one repayment
HSBC£1,000–£30,000; up to 60 months to £15,000 and up to 96 months above £15,000; quick decision statedDisplayed price 3.3; not labelled APRBorrowers needing a stated range and longer term
LloydsDedicated debt-consolidation route; Halifax directs new applicants thereDisplayed price 3.9; rate and fees not shownNew applicants replacing Halifax as their starting point
BarclaysDedicated debt-consolidation pageDisplayed price 4.9; APR and fees not shownCustomers seeking a personalised Barclays quote
HalifaxExisting loans remain Halifax; new applications closedDisplayed price 3.9; not a live new-loan routeExisting Halifax borrowers checking their agreement

For source checking, compare the NatWest debt-consolidation page, the HSBC personal-loan page and the Lloyds debt-consolidation page directly. Ask each lender for the representative APR, total amount repayable, monthly payment, term, late-payment charges and any early-repayment conditions.

Which borrower should choose which route?

Choose NatWest if your main problem is managing several monthly payments and you want the product page to address that use case directly. Choose HSBC if you need between £1,000 and £30,000 and want a clearly published term structure before requesting a quote. Choose Lloyds if you arrived through Halifax’s old loan page and need the current route for a new application.

Barclays belongs on a shortlist only after it supplies the missing cost details. Halifax should not be treated as available to new borrowers. Most importantly, do not accept a longer term simply because the monthly payment looks easier: calculate the total repayment and confirm that every old balance will be cleared.

For a deeper look at how a low advertised rate can still come with strict pricing, read Barclays Personal Loan: Low Rates, Strict Pricing. It is a useful next step before comparing personalised offers.

You might also like

Halifax Debt Consolidation Loan

Halifax Debt Consolidation Loan

Halifax

Rate
3.9–29.9%
Amount
£1k–£50k
Lloyds Bank Debt Consolidation Loan

Lloyds Bank Debt Consolidation Loan

Lloyds Bank

Rate
3.9–29.9%
Amount
£1k–£50k
Barclayloan Debt Consolidation

Barclayloan Debt Consolidation

Barclays

Rate
4.9–29.9%
Amount
£1k–£25k
NatWest Debt Consolidation Loan

NatWest Debt Consolidation Loan

NatWest

Rate
3.9–29.9%
Amount
£1k–£50k

More articles